Show Synopsis: Cathy, a struggling actress, and Jamie, an author, tell the story of their five-year relationship in this song cycle. Cathy's story goes in reverse while Jamie's goes in order, and they only meet in the middle at their wedding. After dating and marrying, Jamie finds that he can't keep himself from cheating on Cathy, and they divorce. Character: Cathy Hiatt, an actress who transforms backwards from feeling helpless and disbelieving about her relationship with Jamie to fresh-faced and optimistic about her career and love life; not exceedingly self-confident but a hard worker. Song Context: Jamie has left Cathy and their marriage for good, and she knows that he is with another woman. She grieves for the love that they had and that she felt so intensely. Fun Facts: 1) The role of Cathy is based on Jason Robert Brown's relationship and former marriage with Theresa O'Neill. O'Neill threatened to sue Brown if it was too biographical, so he rewrote a song into "Shiksa Goddess" to lessen the similarity. 2) Betsy Wolfe, who played Cathy in the 2013 Off-Broadway revival of The Last Five Years, previously performed on Broadway with Sherie Rene Scott in Scott's semi-autobiographical musical Everyday Rapture. Scott played the role of Cathy in the original Chicago production and sang the role on the original cast recording. 3) The cost of making a cast recording was rising rapidly, so the original cast recording of The Last Five Years was made by the small record company Scott and her husband had founded, Sh-K-Boom Records.
"Jamie is over and Jamie is gone. Jamie's decided it's time to move on. Jamie has new dreams he's building upon And I'm still hurting. Jamie arrived at the end of the line. Jamie's convinced that the problems are mine. Jamie is probably feeling just fine And I'm still hurting. What about lies, Jamie? What about things That you swore to be true? What about you, Jamie? What about you? Jamie is sure something wonderful died. Jamie decides it's his right to decide. Jamie's got secrets he doesn't confide And I'm still hurting. Go and hide and run away, Run away, run, and find something better. Go and ride the sun away. Run away like it's simple, Like it's right. Give me a day, Jamie. Bring back the lies, Hang them back on the wall. Maybe I'd see How you could be So certain that we Had no chance at all. Jamie is over and where can I turn? Covered with scars I did nothing to earn. Maybe there's somewhere a lesson to learn But that wouldn't change the fact, That wouldn't speed the time Once the foundation's cracked And I'm Still hurting."